Why does some sins lead to death (1 John 5:16)?


By BibleAsk Team

The concept of sin leading to death is a significant theological theme found in various passages throughout the Bible, including 1 John 5:16. To thoroughly explore this topic, we will delve into the biblical text, examine theological perspectives, and consider practical implications for Christian living. In particular, we will focus on the insights provided by 1 John 5:16 in the NKJV translation of the Bible and how it sheds light on the distinction between sins that lead to death and those that do not.

Understanding 1 John 5:16:

The passage reads as follows:

“If anyone sees his brother sinning a sin which does not lead to death, he will ask, and He will give him life for those who commit sin not leading to death. There is sin leading to death. I do not say that he should pray about that.”

Exploring the Text:

  1. Discerning Sins:
    • Sin Not Leading to Death: In this verse, John acknowledges that some sins committed by believers do not lead to spiritual death. These may include acts of weakness, ignorance, or unintentional wrongdoing that, while still sinful, do not result in the severance of one’s relationship with God.
    • Sin Leading to Death: Conversely, John identifies a category of sin that leads to death. This suggests sins of a more serious nature, such as deliberate and persistent rebellion against God, apostasy, or moral depravity, which have grave spiritual consequences.
  2. Intercession and Life:
    • Prayer for Restoration: John encourages believers to pray for fellow believers who commit sins not leading to death. Through intercession, God grants life and forgiveness to those who repent and turn away from their sinful behavior.
    • Restriction on Prayer: However, John makes it clear that he does not recommend praying for those who commit sins leading to death. This indicates the severity of such sins and the finality of their spiritual condition, which may preclude the possibility of repentance and restoration.

Theological Perspectives:

Degrees of Responsibility: While any sin, if persisted in, will lead to death (Ezekiel 18:4, 24; James 1:15), there is a difference in the degree to which any particular sin will bring a man near to death. This perspective suggests that sins leading to death involve deliberate and persistent rebellion against God, while sins not leading to death may be committed out of weakness, ignorance, or momentary lapses in judgment.

The sins committed by those who are genuinely eager to serve God, but who suffer from a weakness or an evil habit are very different from those sins that are deliberately committed with willful rebellion against the Lord. So, it is more the attitude and the motive that determine the difference, than the act of sin itself. This difference is illustrated in the story of Saul and David. Saul sinned, and did not repent; David sinned, but seriously repented from his sin. Saul died, without the hope of having eternal life; David was forgiven and given the assurance of God’s salvation.

    Practical Implications and Application:

    1. Discernment and Compassion:
      • Spiritual Discernment: Believers are called to exercise spiritual discernment in distinguishing between sins that lead to death and those that do not. This involves understanding the gravity of sin and its consequences, as well as extending compassion and support to those who struggle with sin.
      • Intercessory Prayer: Christians are encouraged to engage in intercessory prayer for fellow believers who have fallen into sin, trusting in God’s mercy and grace to bring about repentance, restoration, and spiritual renewal.
    2. Personal Responsibility and Accountability:
      • Personal Examination: Believers are exhorted to examine their own lives and hearts, acknowledging their need for God’s forgiveness and grace. This involves taking responsibility for one’s actions, repenting of sin, and seeking reconciliation with God and others. Through repentance, faith, and reliance on God’s grace, believers can experience forgiveness, restoration, and eternal life in Christ. As Christians, we are called to live lives of holiness, righteousness, and obedience to God’s commandments, trusting in His mercy and transforming power to overcome sin and death.
      • Accountability in Community: Christians are also accountable to one another within the community of faith, providing mutual support, encouragement, and correction in the pursuit of holiness and spiritual growth.


    In conclusion, 1 John 5:16 offers valuable insights into the distinction between sins that lead to death and those that do not. While all sin separates humanity from God and leads to spiritual death, some sins may be of a more serious nature, resulting in irreversible spiritual consequences. As believers, we are called to exercise spiritual discernment, engage in intercessory prayer, and take personal responsibility for our actions. Ultimately, our hope rests in God’s mercy and grace, which offer forgiveness, restoration, and eternal life to all who turn to Him in repentance and faith.

    In His service,
    BibleAsk Team

    Leave a Reply

    Notify of
    Inline Feedbacks
    View all comments