Why did a prophet lie to another prophet (1 Kings 13)?

Author: BibleAsk Team

The story of the prophet who lied to another prophet in 1 Kings 13 presents a deceptive narrative within the context of biblical prophecy and divine communication. In this comprehensive analysis, we will delve into the intricate details of this account, exploring the motivations, implications, and theological insights surrounding the deception, as well as its relevance for contemporary readers.

Summary of the Story – 1 Kings 13

The narrative unfolds in 1 Kings 13, where an unnamed prophet from Judah is sent by God to prophesy against the altar in Bethel, which King Jeroboam had erected for idolatrous worship. Following God’s command, the prophet delivers a powerful message, causing the altar to split apart. Afterward, Jeroboam invites the prophet to his house for a meal, but the prophet refuses, obeying God’s command not to eat or drink in that place.

Meanwhile, an older prophet residing in Bethel learns of the miraculous signs performed by the visiting prophet. Moved by an evil spirit, the older prophet sets out to intercept the visiting prophet and deceive him. Claiming to have received a divine revelation, the older prophet invites the visiting prophet to his house for a meal. Despite the visiting prophet’s initial refusal based on God’s command, the older prophet persuades him with a false fabricated message from an angel. As a result, the visiting prophet disobeys God’s command and partakes of the meal at the older prophet’s house.

Following this act of disobedience, the visiting prophet is confronted by God’s judgment through the older prophet, who reveals the consequences of his deception. Tragically, the visiting prophet meets a violent end on his journey home, fulfilling the word of the Lord spoken through the older prophet.

Interpretive Challenges

The story of the false prophet’s deception raises several interpretive challenges and theological questions that warrant exploration:

a. The Nature of Divine Communication: One of the central themes of this narrative is obedience to God’s clear commands.

b. The Problem of Deception: 1 Kings 13:11 speaks of a false prophet used by Satan to lie to another godly prophet and ruin God’s plan and cause disgrace to His messenger. The false prophet gave a false message claiming that it was from God. This message should not have been heeded by the true prophet. For the Lord never sends contradictory messages by His prophets.

The false prophet did what Satan did in the garden of Eden. When God had forbidden man to eat of the tree of knowledge of good and evil under pain of death, Satan through the serpent came with the contradictory message, “Ye shall not surely die” (Genesis 3:4). The false prophet lied as Satan, who “is a liar and the father of lies” (John 8:44).

The true prophet had his instructions first from God, and had twice voiced them as reasons for refusing to give ear to a contrary call (verses 8, 9, 16, 17). In going contrary to the express directions from the Lord, he was placing himself on Satan’s ground, where the Lord could not help him. And the man of God was brought to see his mistake by words delivered by the messenger of Satan. As a result, a lion killed the prophet that didn’t obey God.

c. The Sovereignty of God: Throughout the narrative, God’s sovereignty is evident in orchestrating events and fulfilling His word. The lesson that the Lord wanted the nation of Israel to learn from this story was that disobedience leads to death.  In mercy, God sent the nation of Israel a series of signs to warn them from the judgements that will befall them if they don’t repent.

At that time, the Lord caused the withered arm of the king (1 Kings 13:4), the alter to split apart (1 Kings 13:5), and finally the swift death of the prophet who had gone contrary to the Lord’s command (1 Kings 13:24). All these signs should have caused them to awaken. But the nation refused to see God’s disapproval with their disobedience and didn’t heed all these warnings.

Theological Reflections

a. Human Fallibility and Vulnerability: The story of the prophet’s deception underscores the inherent vulnerability of human prophets, despite their divine calling. Prophets, like all individuals, are susceptible to temptation, deception, and moral failure if they are not watching unto prayer.

b. Accountability and Consequences: The narrative highlights the principle of accountability and the inevitable consequences of disobedience. Even those who have received divine revelations are not exempt from the moral law and the repercussions of their actions.

c. God’s Judgment and Mercy: While the visiting prophet faces severe judgment for his disobedience, the story also reveals God’s mercy in providing warnings and opportunities for repentance. Despite the tragic outcome, God’s justice is tempered with compassion and the offer of forgiveness.

Practical Applications

a. Discernment and Integrity: The story serves as a cautionary tale for believers, emphasizing the importance of discernment, integrity, and obedience to God not man in spiritual matters. Christians are called to test the spirits, hold fast to the truth, and resist the allure of deception (1 John 4:1; Ephesians 6:14).

b. Humility and Accountability: The narrative reminds believers of the importance of humility, accountability, and transparency in their spiritual journeys. No one needs to fail, and obedience and accountablility help safeguard against deception and moral compromise.

c. Faithfulness in Ministry: For those called to ministry or leadership roles, the story serves as a sobering reminder of the weighty responsibility entrusted to them. Faithfulness, integrity, and obedience to God’s commands are essential for effective and fruitful ministry.


    The story of the false prophet who lied to another prophet in 1 Kings 13 presents a thought-provoking narrative that invites readers to grapple with issues of divine communication, human fallibility, and moral responsibility. The narrative ultimately points to timeless truths about the importance of discernment, integrity, and obedience in the Christian life. As believers navigate the complexities of faith and ministry, may they heed the warnings and wisdom embedded within this ancient tale, remaining steadfast in their commitment to truth, righteousness, and obedience to God.

    In His service,
    BibleAsk Team

    Leave a Comment