Why does Jesus say that His witness is not true in John 5:31 and then contradicts that in John 8:14?

Posted on

John 8:14 appears from the surface to contradict John 5:31. But there is no contradiction because the two verses took place in two different settings and bear different meanings. In each situation, Jesus’ words were given to meet the thinking of His hearers. Let’s look at these two verses closely:

It is important to note that according to Jewish tradition and law, “No one may testify concerning himself” (Mishnah Kethuboth 2. 9, Soncino ed. of the Talmud, p. 151).

So, in John 5:31 where it says, “If I bear witness of Myself, My witness is not true,” Jesus’ statement was intended to show the Mishnah type of thinking among His Jewish hearers. Christ wanted to demonstrate His complete reliance upon His Father by referring to the works that He was doing as an evidence of His claims (John 5:36, 37). To stress His point, He reminded His audience of this Jewish principle that a testimony regarding one’s own conduct was not considered valid.

In John 8:14 where it says, “Jesus answered and said to them, ‘Even if I bear witness of Myself, My witness is true, for I know where I came from and where I am going; but you do not know where I come from and where I am going'” here, the situation is different. The speech was not in regard to Jesus’ relation to the Father, but rather to His declaration, “I am the light of the world,” which the Pharisees rejected because He said it of Himself. To their objection Jesus claimed, nevertheless, that His words were true.

In His service,
BibleAsk Team

Thank you for visiting BibleAsk – an online ministry dedicated to providing Bible based answers to your questions. If you enjoyed and agree with this answer, please like and share! If you don’t agree, please leave a comment below, and we’ll be sure to respond! If you have another question you would like to ask, please click here and someone from our team will personally answer it (don’t worry, your email address will never be shared). Check out our Bible Answers page to see just Bible verses answering thousands of questions. If you feel impressed to support this ministry, kindly visit our donate page to send a tax-deductible love gift to BibleAsk. Any donation size helps .

Sign Up for Our Updates

Get notified of our latest updates. Don't worry, they're occasional :)

You May Also Like